Pappardelle With Lobster – Red Lobster Copycat Recipe
This Red Lobster copycat pappardelle with lobster features tender lobster tossed with wide pappardelle noodles in a rich, creamy garlic sauce. The silky pasta ribbons hold the sauce beautifully, creating a luxurious seafood dinner that feels special but is simple to prepare. Inspired by the restaurant favorite, this dish is perfect for entertaining or date night at home.

Lets hear it for pappardelle with lobster in a luxurious garlic herb sauce with tender crisp asparagus and sweet and savory cherry tomatoes.
A classic entrée that brings together so many cravings on one plate with bite sized lobster morsels that are the true gems in this dish.
We have a favorite Red Lobster copycat baked lobster tails recipe that we always start with for our dishes that feature lobster meat.
And the lobster tails always turn out fantastic with a perfect blend of savory seasonings that accentuate any dinner.
Additionally, sauteed cherry tomatoes and tender crisp asparagus in a garlic lemon butter herb sauce is a combination that always puts it over the top. Plus, when you make this in your own kitchen, you can feel free to add more asparagus and tomatoes than would otherwise be served.
Not to mention, pappardelle noodles are one of the most comforting pasta shapes. The way the noodles can gather the sauce and toppings in just the right amount – it’s true perfection in every bite.
If you’re a fan of seafood, check out our collection of easy Red Lobster Copycat Recipes! And this post about what to do with lobster for more recipes and ideas. Plus, make the most of asparagus season with more ideas for what to do with asparagus!
Content of this Post
- Why You'll Love Pappardelle With Lobster
- What is Pappardelle?
- Ingredients in Pappardelle With Lobster
- Garlic Sauce Ingredients
- Equipment Needed
- How To Make Pappardelle With Lobster
- STEP 1 – Bake Lobster Tails
- STEP 2 – Cook Pappardelle To Package Directions
- STEP 3 – Make The Garlic Herb Sauce
- STEP 4 – Sauté Asparagus and Cherry Tomatoes
- STEP 5 – Combine Ingredients and Serve
- What To Serve With Pappardelle With Lobster
- More Red Lobster Copycat Recipes
- You'll Also Love
Why You’ll Love Pappardelle With Lobster
Although this is an impressive dish in both flavor and presentation, it is rather quick and easy to make. With a little advance preparation, you can easily pull this off!
Pop the lobster tails in the oven and while they bake, you can cook the pappardelle to package directions (about 7 minutes in boiling water) to arrive at al dente (cooked but still firm).
Meanwhile, on the stove top you can sauté the asparagus and cherry tomatoes in a skillet with a little butter or oil and fresh garlic.
Or if you’d prefer to bake them, put them in a separate dish, into the oven with the lobster tails. Just be sure to not overcook them, remember to check on them every so often.
The garlic butter sauce for the pasta is easy to make on the stove top as well, and takes only a few minutes. When everything is done, just toss it all together, put in a serving dish and enjoy!
With a little multi tasking, this extremely flavorful and phenomenal dish for a dinner party comes together in no time.
And if you love sauteed asparagus with tomatoes, you’re going to be over the moon with our super easy and popular asparagus cucumber tomato salad.
What is Pappardelle?
Pappardelle is a type of broad ribbon shaped noodle, that is long and wider than fettucine and traditionally made with eggs.
It originated in the Tuscan region of Italy and is typically served with hearty sauces. In Italian, the word pappardelle comes from “pappare” and translates to “to gobble up”.
Pappardelle pairs well with rich and creamy sauces as well as light ones. As a child, I loved pappardelle in a plainer form with butter and parmesan. Still delicious!
Ingredients in Pappardelle With Lobster
In this recipe we use common ingredients to make the sauce that you may have on hand. The pappardelle, asparagus, lobster and cherry tomatoes should also be available in most supermarkets.

- Pappardelle — dried egg based pappardelle noodles that will need to be cooked according to the package directions.
- Lobster — seasoned or plain buttered lobster meat from our baked lobster tails recipe. We had about a cup when it was chopped, but feel free to add more lobster to this. You can certainly use lobster meat from a whole lobster or claws. TIP: reserve some of the best pieces of lobster for the top of the dish to enhance the presentation.
- Asparagus — use a bunch of asparagus, roughly a cup when chopped down. Or feel free to use more or less.
- Cherry Tomatoes — or grape tomatoes that you can cut in half. We use about a cup or so, but you can adjust to your preference.
Garlic Sauce Ingredients
- Butter — either regular salted or unsalted butter is fine, but you may need to add a little more salt if you’re using unsalted butter.
- Flour — all purpose flour
- Broth — use a seafood broth or even chicken broth will work in this dish.
- Lemon Juice — freshly squeezed lemon juice
- Garlic — two cloves of garlic is a good amount in this recipe. Go ahead and adjust this amount to your preference for garlic.
- Herbs — we used fresh parsley because we had that on hand, but more herbs can be used. A little bit of freshly chopped dill would be excellent as well.
- Salt — use according to your preference or omit if you wish. We found a half teaspoon to be a good amount in this recipe.
Equipment Needed
How To Make Pappardelle With Lobster
STEP 1 – Bake Lobster Tails
You can use any cooked lobster meat, from a whole lobster, claws, etc. and you may like to reserve the nicest pieces of lobster for accentuating the top of the dish when serving. If you already have cooked lobster meat, you can skip this step.
Follow the link to our baked lobster tails recipe for thorough instruction on how to cook them.
Essentially, the steps are to preheat the oven to 450°F. Get a pair of clean kitchen scissors and cut upward through the center of the lobster tail shell.

Pull the lobster meat up through the cut you just made with the scissors. Fold the lobster meat over as shown in the picture and place in a small oven safe dish.

You can bake the lobster with seasoning as shown below or with just butter and garlic, however you prefer. We have used a silicone basting brush to brush on some melted butter with seasoning that we like a lot, but it is not necessary. Brush on melted butter with garlic and lemon if you like it that way.

Bake the lobster tails in the preheated oven for 12-15 minutes or until the lobster tails have reached a safe internal temperature of 135-140°F. Be sure to use a digital thermometer inserted into the thickest part of the meat.
As well, follow the guidelines set by NOAA Fisheries for sustainable seafood.
STEP 2 – Cook Pappardelle To Package Directions
While the lobster tails are in the oven, cook pappardelle pasta as per the package instructions. Place the pasta in boiling water and allow to cook for about 7 minutes until al dente (cooked yet firm).
Safely drain in a colander and set aside.
STEP 3 – Make The Garlic Herb Sauce
In a skillet or saucepan on medium heat, melt the butter. Add the minced garlic and flour. Whisk the flour with the melted butter until it forms a smooth mixture.
Then add the broth and lemon juice, and raise the temperature on the stove to medium high.
Allow the sauce to come to a boil, and whisk constantly to arrive at a smooth sauce. When the sauce boils, it will thicken. You can remove the skillet or saucepan from heat and add the herbs. Set aside.

STEP 4 – Sauté Asparagus and Cherry Tomatoes
In a skillet on medium heat, heat butter or oil and add the asparagus. We’ve used the bottom of our tagine here.
Since the asparagus takes longer to cook through than the cherry tomatoes, we’ll add the cherry tomatoes in a few minutes. Sauté the asparagus and stir often to ensure they don’t burn.

When the asparagus are tender but still firm, add the halved cherry tomatoes and stir for a minute or two.
When the asparagus and cherry tomatoes are cooked, remove from heat and add the lobster pieces to warm them. You can put in some parsley and other herbs as well at this stage if you like.

STEP 5 – Combine Ingredients and Serve
Once the pappardelle is ready, drain it carefully in a colander. Now it’s time to assemble the dish.
You’ll need to combine the ingredients in a pan or bowl large enough to hold the pappardelle pasta, vegetables, lobster and sauce.
We chose to mix in our tagine base as shown below, although a separate large bowl or pot would be great to use.
Pour the sauce over top of the vegetables and stir.

Next, add the pappardelle noodles and toss well with the vegetable, lobster and sauce. Be sure to combine thoroughly so that the sauce and vegetables are well incorporated throughout.

Transfer to a serving dish and garnish with parsley. Try to arrange with the nicest lobster pieces on top for a lovely presentation.

What To Serve With Pappardelle With Lobster
Red Lobster has a number of new menu items currently with its pappardelle with lobster.
There is a parmesan crusted chicken dish on the menu as well as lemon basil mahi. Some appetizers are bacon wrapped scallops with spring mix and the ever popular crab queso.
You can do any of the classic Red Lobster inspired appetizers, like escargot stuffed mushrooms, crab stuffed mushrooms, crab pita pizza, and lobster artichoke dip. Mussels in white wine sauce would be an excellent appetizer as well.
We love garlic shrimp scampi as well. You can’t go wrong with adding garlic shrimp to any seafood dinner.
All of these copycat recipe options are easy to make at home. We prepare them all the time and they are really quite simple.

More Red Lobster Copycat Recipes
Red Lobster Inspired Appetizers
Red Lobster Style Mains
Red Lobster Inspired Sides
You’ll Also Love
Red Lobster Crab Alfredo Linguini and Shrimp Scampi

Did you try this recipe?
We’d love for you to share it on
and give it
Pappardelle With Lobster – Red Lobster Copycat Recipe
Equipment
Ingredients
- ½ Pounds Pappardelle
- 1 Cup Asparagus
- 1 Cup Cherry Tomatoes, halved
- 1 Cup Lobster Meat, taken from two lobster tails, or any cooked lobster meat, cut into bite sized pieces
Instructions
Bake Lobster Tails (or skip this step if you already have cooked lobster meat)
- Preheat oven to 450℉. Melt 3 tablespoons butter and add seasonings to it if you like or keep it plain buttered. We usually add about a teaspoon each of salt, pepper, garlic, paprika, hot sauce and parsley.


- Place lobster tails in oven safe dish. Use clean kitchen scissors to cut upward through the center of the lobster tail shell.


- Pull lobster meat up through the center cut you just made with the scissors. Fold the lobster meat over as shown in the picture. Use a silicon kitchen brush to brush on the seasoned (or plain) melted butter. Transfer the oven safe dish with lobster tails to the preheated oven. Bake for 12-15 minutes or until the lobster tails have reached a safe temperature. Measure with a digital thermometer inserted into the thickest part to ensure the lobster tails have reached an internal temperature of 135-140℉. Allow lobster tails to cool enough to be handled and then separate the lobster meat from the shell and chop the lobster into bite sized pieces. While the lobster is in the oven, cook pappardelle to package directions, about 7 minutes in boiling water. You'll want the noodles to be al dente (cooked but still firm). Carefully drain in a colander and set aside when done.


Make The Garlic Herb Sauce
- Melt butter in a saucepan or skillet over medium heat. Add minced garlic and flour. Whisk the butter and flour mixture until the flour is thoroughly mixed into the butter.


- Pour in the broth and lemon juice. Whisk mixture until it is well combined and smooth. Raise temperature to medium high heat and allow the sauce to come to a boil. As the sauce boils, it will thicken.


- Once the sauce has boiled, remove from heat. Add in the chopped herbs (parsley, etc.). Set aside.


Prepare the Asparagus
- Prepare the asparagus by washing them, and snapping the tough bottom ends off of each stalk. Then cut into approximately 2 inch sticks.


Sauté The Asparagus and Cherry Tomatoes
- Heat butter or oil in a skillet (we used our tagine base) and add the asparagus sticks to cook. Since they take longer to cook than the cherry tomatoes, we will add the cherry tomatoes afterward. Sauté asparagus for a few minutes until they become tender crisp.


- Add the cherry tomatoes and stir fry them for a minute or two. They won't need to cook for long and be careful to not overcook them. Once the cherry tomatoes are cooked, remove from heat and then you can add the cooked lobster and herbs.


Assemble The Pappardelle With Lobster
- Pour the sauce in with the vegetables and lobster. Mix well.


- Now to add the pasta, you'll need a large heat safe bowl or pot, large enough to fit the pappardelle pasta, vegetables, lobster and sauce. We chose to mix everything in our tagine base since it is deep enough, although a large bowl or pot would work nicely as well.


- Combine all of the ingredients and give a good stir to incorporate the sauce with the pappardelle.


- Transfer to a serving dish. Arrange some lobster on top and add any reserved lobster pieces to top the dish for presentation purposes.


Nutrition
Note
This recipe is provided for informational purposes only. The above nutritional values are estimates and should only be used as a guide. Please use proper food safety practices, always use a food thermometer to ensure safe cooking temperature, and consult a professional if you have dietary restrictions or allergies.












