easy oreo ice cream cake featured 2

Easy Oreo Ice Cream Cake

Home » Recipes » Course » Dessert » Easy Oreo Ice Cream Cake

Always in style, this easy Oreo ice cream cake is a super easy recipe to follow for a homemade restaurant style copycat dessert.

 

This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Please read our disclosure policy and terms.

 
Sharing is Caring! Pin! Share! Post
easy oreo ice cream cake pin

When it’s time to choose a flavor combo at our house, nine times out of ten it’s an Oreo ice cream cake. Sure, others are great at times, but we always come back to a cookies and cream or Oreo cake.

It reminds us of Dairy Queen Oreo ice cream cake. It is certainly satisfying and you won’t miss the store bought ice cream cakes.

And although there are other flavor combos, none have the same universal appeal as the Oreo ice cream cake. It seems, in our experience, that an Oreo ice cream cake is preferred over other flavor choices.

Content in this Post

Every time we make these, we are blown away by how great they taste and we are always so proud of how well these cakes turn out.

A homemade Oreo ice cream cake is an impressive dessert option any time of year.

This ice cream cake is similar to our easy 5 minute ice cream cake recipe that we’ve customized with an Easter theme.

Love ice cream cakes? Be sure to check out our homemade ice cream cake recipes for more custom cake inspiration. We share our easy failproof method in how to make an ice cream cake.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

  • Super Easy — This ice cream cake recipe is so simple.
  • Highly Customizable — There are no limits to the combinations of ice cream flavors and cookie types you can use in this amazing dessert.
  • Choose Your Ice Cream Types — You can replace refined sugar laden ice creams with better for you, homemade options. Or keep it simple with two packages of your favorite store bought brands.
  • Convenient — With a silicone Bundt pan, it’s easy to stack the ice cream and cookies right into it when assembling. You can remove the ice cream cake without issues when you use a silicone Bundt plan. Plus, the ring shape of the Bundt allows for easier slicing of the ice cream cake when it’s time to serve.
  • Presentation — Not only is this Oreo ice cream cake so easy, but when you release it from the Bundt pan, it’s truly a sight to behold. And, you can decorate it in no time with Magic Shell chocolate sauce, whipped cream, Oreo cookies and more. And, when you cut into it, you’ll reveal the lovely interior of the ice cream cake.
  • Economical — If you’re looking to save a few bucks, you can keep the total price of a homemade ice cream cake down significantly from any you’d purchase at an ice cream place. Especially if you need ice cream cakes often, with a larger family and lots of Birthday’s to celebrate. It’s also perfect for the many holidays and occasions throughout the year. Customize it for Easter, Halloween, Thanksgiving, Christmas, Valentine’s Day and more!
  • Saves Time — This only takes a few minutes to assemble and in the long run, you’ll save time by not having to drive to an ice cream shop and back home again. This ice cream cake is easy to prep ahead several days in advance and keep in the freezer until needed.
easy homemade ice cream cake recipe customized with Easter egg theme
Easy Homemade Ice Cream Cake Customized For Easter Egg Theme and Chocolate Magic Shell Nest

Easy Oreo Ice Cream Cake Ingredients

The ingredients shown and listed below serve as a general representation of the recipe. For a complete list of ingredients, measurements and helpful tips, please refer to our recipe card. Jump to Recipe
easy oreo ice cream cake ingredients mise en place
  • Oreo Cookies – You’ll need about 16 Oreo cookies – 8 cookies to crush for the ice cream cake itself, and then another 8 cookies for decorating on top.
  • Ice Cream Flavor #1 – Choose your favorite here. We have Cookie Dough ice cream in ours, although you can certainly substitute others, like Oreo ice cream or cookies and cream.
  • Ice Cream Flavor #2 – Pick another favorite ice cream that will pair well with the first flavor and Oreos. We love a rich chocolate ice cream like Kawartha Chocolate, among others.
  • Ice Cream Sandwiches – Adding a layer of ice cream sandwich to the top (that will become the bottom when flipped over) makes a nice base for the cake. The ice cream sandwiches easily add more texture and interest to the cake. You can swap it for other cookies, even chocolate chip cookies would work well if arranged to completely cover the second ice cream layer. We needed 7 ice cream sandwiches in our recipe below.
  • Magic Shell Chocolate Sauce – We find Magic Shell to be very convenient as it instantly hardens up to create a decorative chocolate sauce. But you can substitute other thick chocolate sauces and icings if you’d rather. Remember to work fast when decorating because it is ice cream and will begin to melt.

Save or Share this Recipe

on your favorite platforms

How To Make An Oreo Ice Cream Cake

Subscribe to our YouTube channel

The steps listed below serve as a general guide on how to make the recipe. For a complete list of step-by-step instructions with cook times and temperatures, please refer to our recipe card. Jump to Recipe

This is an unbelievably simple recipe that you’ll love to prepare again and again. It comes in handy all year long, and you can make it a little different each time.

STEP 1 – Crush or Chop Oreos

There are a number of ways to crush Oreos, but we prefer this simple method of cutting with a butter knife. Just chop it up with a few vertical cuts.

easy oreo ice cream cake step 1a

Then use the knife to make horizontal cuts. This is an easy way to get good sized Oreo chunks that you’ll appreciate in the cake. If you prefer smaller pieces, feel free to crush them.

easy oreo ice cream cake step 1b

You’ll want to crush about 8 Oreo cookies, and divide in half, using 4 crushed cookies for each layer in the cake. Remember, you’ll need another 8 Oreos to decorate the cake later on, so 16 Oreos total are need for the cake plus garnish.

STEP 2 – Cookies and Ice Cream Layer #1

Take the two ice cream tubs out of the freezer about 5 minutes before you’ll begin assembling. So that they’ll have a chance to melt a little and be easier to scoop.

You don’t want the ice creams to be overly or completely melted though, just enough to be easy to scoop and flatten.

Put a layer of crushed Oreos (about 4 crushed Oreos) evenly at the bottom of the Bundt pan.

easy oreo ice cream cake step 2

Then, add the first layer of ice cream. Pat it down flat and smooth with a spoon or spatula.

easy oreo ice cream cake step 3

STEP 3 – Cookies and Ice Cream Layer #2

Arrange the second layer of crushed Oreos (about 4 cookies) evenly over the top of the first ice cream type.

easy oreo ice cream cake step 4

Scoop the second layer of ice cream into the Bundt pan. Use a spoon to flatten and smooth it. When filling with ice cream, leave some space at the top to add the ice cream sandwiches in the next step. It’s quite melted, but don’t worry, it will be fine as it’s going into the freezer soon.

easy oreo ice cream cake step 5

Remove ice cream sandwiches from their packaging and arrange them over top of the second ice cream layer. Press them into the ice cream slightly. You can cut the last one to fit in the corners and empty spaces. Remember to work as quick as you can in this step.

easy oreo ice cream cake step 6

STEP 4 – Cover and Freeze

Wrap the ice cream cake in the Bundt form, tightly with aluminum foil and place in the freezer. Allow the ice cream cake to set for at least four hours and ideally overnight. This can be prepared a few days in advance of the party.

easy oreo ice cream cake step 7

STEP 5 – Decorate Ice Cream Cake

After removing the ice cream cake from the freezer, carefully release it from the silicone Bundt pan and turn it onto a serving plate.

easy oreo ice cream cake step 10

Vigorously shake the container of Magic Shell chocolate sauce for a minute. Pour a generous amount in a round motion over top of the cake.

easy oreo ice cream cake step 10a

Shake a can of whipped cream and place whipped cream around the cake in 8 dollops.

easy oreo ice cream cake step 10b

Rest an Oreo cookie next to each whipped cream dollop.

easy oreo ice cream cake step 11

Serve immediately and enjoy it! Here’s a look at the interior of this gorgeous Oreo ice cream cake.

easy oreo ice cream cake recipe 2

What To Serve With Oreo Ice Cream Cake

An Oreo ice cream cake is an impressive dessert centerpiece that can stand alone. You don’t need any additional desserts, but if you’d like to add more treats, you certainly can.

Feel free to serve with additional candies, cookies, cakes, cupcakes and more. Whatever your heart’s desire, in the dessert category, will likely pair well with an Oreo cake.

More Easy Ice Cream Cake Recipes

Here are some of our favorite go-to ice cream cakes that are perfect for any celebration at home.

We include videos in each recipe post to show how easy they are to make. And, you can watch them all in our ice cream cake playlist on You Tube.

You’ll Also Love

Another failproof dessert recipe, that can be prepared last minute and is delightful for guests is this Crock-Pot Chocolate Fondue. You can’t go wrong with this one!

slow cooker chocolate fondue featured

Did you try this recipe?

We’d love for you to share it on

Pinterest Facebook X (Twitter)

and give it

Easy Oreo Ice Cream Cake

Susan & Björn
A simple go-to recipe for a homemade Oreo ice cream cake that rivals any store bought. Easy to prepare and decorate, you'll be amazed at how well it turns out.
Use a silicone Bundt pan for ease of assembling the cake, ease to remove the cake from the pan and so easy to cut and serve the slices compared with other ice cream cake shapes.
No ratings yet
servings10
Prep Time 5 minutes
Freeze Time 6 hours
Total Time 5 minutes
Course Dessert
Cuisine American
Calories 991 kcal
Fiber 4 g
Carbohydrates 129 g

Ingredients
 
 

For The Oreo Ice Cream Cake

  • 8 Oreos, crushed, divided
  • 1¾ Quart Cookie Dough Ice Cream, Note: you can eyeball the amount of ice cream needed by filling the Bundt about halfway with one type of ice cream and the remaining half with the second type.
  • 1¾ Quart Chocolate Ice Cream, Note: you can eyeball the amount of ice cream needed by filling the Bundt about halfway with one type of ice cream and the remaining half with the second type.
  • 7 Ice Cream Sandwiches

For Cake Decorating

  • ½ Cup Magic Shell
  • 2 Cups Whipped Cream
  • 8 Oreo Cookies


Instructions
 

Crush or Chop Oreos

  • Use a butter knife to chop Oreo cookies, making cuts across vertically and horizontally for small Oreo chunks.
    You'll need 16 Oreos total: 8 for crushing and layering, and 8 for decorating the cake later.
    easy oreo ice cream cake step 1b

Assemble Oreo Ice Cream Cake

  • Put half of the crushed Oreo (4 crushed Oreos) evenly into the bottom of a silicone Bundt pan.
    easy oreo ice cream cake step 2
  • Scoop the first layer of ice cream into the Bundt, over top of the crushed Oreos. Use a large spoon to press the ice cream flat and smooth. In this case, we have cookie dough ice cream. Although you could substitute with cookies and cream or Oreo ice cream.
    Note: This is the ice cream layer that will be on top when the Bundt is later flipped over.
    easy oreo ice cream cake step 3
  • Put another layer of crushed Oreos (4 crushed Oreos) evenly over top of the first layer of ice cream.
    easy oreo ice cream cake step 4
  • Scoop in the second ice cream flavor. Use a large spoon or spatula to press down the ice cream so that it is even and flat. Here we have chocolate ice cream.
    easy oreo ice cream cake step 5
  • Place ice cream sandwiches on top of the second layer of ice cream and arrange them to fit. You will need to cut some and press them into the ice cream a little.
    easy oreo ice cream cake step 6
  • Cover with aluminum foil. Keep it tightly wrapped and then place into a freezer. Make sure the cake sits level in the freezer. Allow to set in the freezer for at least four hours, preferably over night.
    easy oreo ice cream cake step 7

Decorate Oreo Ice Cream Cake

  • After the ice cream cake has set for a few hours in the freezer, and ideally overnight, you can take it out of the freezer. Carefully release the ice cream cake from the silicone Bundt pan. Turn the ice cream cake over onto a serving plate.
    easy oreo ice cream cake step 10
  • If using Magic Shell, shake it well for a minute. Then squeeze out the chocolate in a circle over the top of the cake.
    easy oreo ice cream cake step 10a
  • Shake a can of whipped cream and use it to decorate with whipped cream over top of the chocolate sauce.
    easy oreo ice cream cake step 10b
  • Arrange Oreo cookies on top of the whipped cream.
    easy oreo ice cream cake step 11
  • Serve immediately and Enjoy!
    easy oreo ice cream cake recipe 4

Video

Nutrition

Calories: 991kcal Carbohydrates: 129g Fiber: 4g Net Carbohydrates: 125g Protein: 16g Fat: 49g Saturated Fat: 27g Polyunsaturated Fat: 3g Monounsaturated Fat: 15g Trans Fat: 0.01g Cholesterol: 149mg Sodium: 450mg Potassium: 905mg Sugar: 101g Vitamin A: 1593IU Vitamin C: 2mg Calcium: 456mg Iron: 4mg

Note

This recipe is provided for informational purposes only. The above nutritional values are estimates and should only be used as a guide. Please use proper food safety practices, always use a food thermometer to ensure safe cooking temperature, and consult a professional if you have dietary restrictions or allergies.

All Spiced Out logo and text
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!
Share and tag us @allspicedout and hashtag #allspicedout

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating